View Poll Results: Which one is better?

Voters
90. You may not vote on this poll
  • Giza Necropolis

    70 77.78%
  • The Great Wall of China

    20 22.22%
Post New Thread
Page 1 of 3
1 2 3 LastLast
Results 1 to 20 of 58

Thread: World Wonder Shodown: Giza Pyramids vs Great Wall of China

  1. #1
    Video Producer Ecto's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2004
    Location
    Copenhagen
    Posts
    741

    World Wonder Shodown: Giza Pyramids vs Great Wall of China

    Alright, people. Here are our contestants:

    Giza Necropolis


    Located in Giza, Egypt, right outside of Cairo lies the Giza Necropolis, consisting of the "great pyramid of Giza" - the Cheops Pyramid. Also included in the excellent package are the Chephren and Mykerinos pyramids, as well as the great sphinx.

    All of the buildings are somewhat shrouded in mystery - from who built them, to how they built them. The Great Pyramid is believed to have been the tomb of the ancient Egyptian king Khufu. However, it was emptied long before any historians or archaeologists were able to enter, and make records of the contents.

    The Sphinx is even more mysterious. Some claim it is not the body of a lion, but of a jackal - an ode the Anubis, Egyptian god of death. Others suggest that it is linked to sun-worship from even before the Giza area was used as a necropolis.

    These magnificent structures have mystified and enthralled humanity for ages.

    The Great Wall


    Stretching from Shanhaiguan in north-eastern China to Lop Nur in north-western China, along the Mongolian/Chinese border, the Great Wall is an imposing monument to how much the Chinese hated the horse people.

    A very utilitarian building, the Great Wall served the purpose that walls quite often serve: keeping unwanted people out. The Wall was built using different techniques in different places - from mud and wood to stone bricks.


    Points of comparison

    Age
    The Pyramids take the first point, having been constructed roughly around 2500 BC. Construction was initially begun on the Great Wall around 500 BC, which while impressive, can hardly compare.

    Time frame
    The Cheops Pyramid is believed to have been constructed over the course of 20 years. In stark contrast, the Great Wall, on the other hand, was continuously constructed, extended and maintained up until the 1500s. Whether you think the Pyramids win for managing construction in a shorter time frame, or the Great Wall wins for persistence, there's no denying that both are impressive.

    Height
    The Pyramids undoubtedly pull out ahead here. Not only does the Cheops Pyramid dwarf the Great Walls 8 metres with its (original) 146.6 metres. The Cheops Pyramid was actually the tallest man made structure in the world for over 3800 years.

    Length
    Unsurprisingly, the Great Wall wins this one supremely. So much so, that measuring it is not a trivial task. Recent estimates put the wall at an incredible 8851.8 km. It's been less than half a year since a new section of wall was discovered.

    Technical prowess
    This one is not easy. The Pyramids are remarkable for the precision with which they were build The Great Pyramid itself is a mere 19 cm from having a perfectly quadratic base. On the other hand, the Great Wall snakes it way through mountains, and has been maintained for a very long time

    Weight
    The Great Pyramid consists of 2.3 million blocks averaging about 2.5 tonnes per block, for a total of roughly 5.7 million tonnes.

    No real scientific attempts have been made at calculating the weight of the Great Wall, as such a task would be completely mammoth. However, one very conservative estimate by some dude (here) puts it between 70 million tonnes and 700 million tonnes. A heavy victory for the Great Wall!

    So, WCR. Which one is better?
    ______________________________
    Contrary to popular belief, the Eskimo does not have one hundred different words for snow. They do, however, have two hundred and thirty-four words for fudge.

  2. #2
    50 Point Level course's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2004
    Posts
    70

    The Great Wall isn't one of the World Wonders.
    ______________________________
    Spoiler
    Excess of feeling avoids feelings. He fled the world because he did not find, in the whole compass of his loving nature, a weapon with which to resist it. He withdrew from his fellow men after he had given them everything and had received nothing in return. He remained alone because he found no second self. But until his death he preserved a human heart for all men, a father's heart for his own people, the whole world.
    - from Beethoven's eulogy by Franz Grillparzer in 1827

  3. #3
    100 Point Level
    Join Date
    May 2008
    Posts
    189

    My heart says great wall my head says pyramids >.<

  4. #4
    Video Producer Ecto's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2004
    Location
    Copenhagen
    Posts
    741

    It's not one of the traditional "Ancient World Wonders". However, it is often cited as a world wonder, and there is no real global authority on it
    ______________________________
    Contrary to popular belief, the Eskimo does not have one hundred different words for snow. They do, however, have two hundred and thirty-four words for fudge.

  5. #5
    50 Point Level course's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2004
    Posts
    70

    Fair enough, it sure is an awesome thing that wall. I still voted pyramids though. Just because they're older.
    ______________________________
    Spoiler
    Excess of feeling avoids feelings. He fled the world because he did not find, in the whole compass of his loving nature, a weapon with which to resist it. He withdrew from his fellow men after he had given them everything and had received nothing in return. He remained alone because he found no second self. But until his death he preserved a human heart for all men, a father's heart for his own people, the whole world.
    - from Beethoven's eulogy by Franz Grillparzer in 1827

  6. #6
    1000 Point Level LordMorvan's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2005
    Location
    Cygnus-X
    Posts
    1,049

    Wall is awesome, but nothing beats the motherfucking Pyramids.
    ______________________________

  7. #7
    50 Point Level Snowi's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2004
    Location
    Orranda
    Posts
    50

    Quote Originally Posted by LordMorvan View Post
    Wall is awesome, but nothing beats the motherfucking Pyramids.

  8. #8
    PINKUS FOREVER fridginators's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2006
    Location
    Sydney, Australia
    Posts
    2,632

    The Wall is certainly a strong contender, but I think it does go to the Necropolis. Pyramids are just badass.
    ______________________________
    [21:36] <@SexehSeacow> Gloop is actually pretty funny
    [21:36] <@SexehSeacow> but sometimes he slips
    [21:36] <kuresuti_> right... it does not show up here in the irc
    [21:36] <@Gloop> [10:37] <@SexehSeacow> Gloop is actually pretty
    [21:37] <@Gloop> YEAHH!
    My political, economic and personal blog: http://jazzcriminals.wordpress.com/
    My music blog: http://oneofuscannotbewrong.wordpress.com/

  9. #9
    1000 Point Level LordMorvan's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2005
    Location
    Cygnus-X
    Posts
    1,049

    Quote Originally Posted by Snowi View Post
    Who's the black private dick
    That's a sex machine to all the chicks?

    SHAFT!!


    ..You're damn right
    ______________________________

  10. #10
    300 Point Level Ishegara's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2004
    Posts
    398

    Pyramids. The Great Wall did not require the same kind of intelligence as the Pyramids, either in the mathematical proportions (which are very interesting) or the construction.

    The Great Wall isn't even consistent from section to section - clearly it's the result of "throw money and people at the problem." It didn't do a very good job either.

  11. #11

    From what I understand, we still don't even know who built the Pyramids and how they did it. Same goes for the Pyramids in southern Africa and South America.

  12. #12
    400 Point Level SkyScream's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2005
    Posts
    406

    Quote Originally Posted by bigyellowtwinki View Post
    From what I understand, we still don't even know who built the Pyramids and how they did it. Same goes for the Pyramids in southern Africa and South America.
    We do, slaves.

  13. #13
    200 Point Level D]v[D's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2005
    Posts
    299

    The answer is in the film AvP.
    ______________________________

  14. #14
    1000 Point Level 66Dragon6's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2005
    Posts
    1,313

    The pyramids were made by aliens
    The wall of china is made by slaves

    Aliens > Slaves
    ______________________________
    Yo sig too big!

  15. #15
    2000 Point Level ex0duz's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2004
    Location
    Master of Past and Present
    Posts
    2,104

    Number of people killed during construction

    Great Wall = Over 900,000!

    Pyramids = Unknown, not many anyway.

    Great Wall = Built/maintained for over 2 millenium(that has got to be the biggest and most impressive man made project ever. 2-3 million deaths, and built over 2 millenia. Shit goes through the most fucked up mountains and rocky passes n shit, it's all good, just straight through, it's the fucking great wall..

    But yeah. Pyramids were built by aliens, so that's definitely a plus for those damn Egyptian bastards.

    Overall Verdict: Great Wall takes it. Length and effort involved is epic. None of this 20 year crap, this is a 2 millenium long and 2-3 million death project.. and with no help from aliens, that's even more impressive.
    ______________________________
    Abstract, Negative, Concrete. Thesis, Antithesis, Synthesis. Bush, Obama, ?
    "I'd tell all my friends but they'd never believe me, They'd think that I'd finally, lost it completely. I'd show them the stars and the meaning of life.. they'd shut me away, But I'll be all right.."

    Anime/Manga List | WCR Otaku Group | The Chess Threadô | Vlog/Blog Thread | Youtube Channel

  16. #16
    2000 Point Level ex0duz's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2004
    Location
    Master of Past and Present
    Posts
    2,104

    Quote Originally Posted by Ishegara View Post
    Pyramids. The Great Wall did not require the same kind of intelligence as the Pyramids, either in the mathematical proportions (which are very interesting) or the construction.

    The Great Wall isn't even consistent from section to section - clearly it's the result of "throw money and people at the problem." It didn't do a very good job either.
    That's the whole point. It's impressive just how much people/money they threw at it, and over how long too. Nothing else(AFAIK) can compare with such a scale of project, in the past or currently.

    But also, i'm sure the chinese could have built the pyramids, they had pretty good technology for back in the day too and came up with plenty of inventions and shit(as much or even more than the Egyptians at least, and none of this was given to them by alien civilizations ).

    And what do you mean by didn't do a very good job? They did the job, or what, did you think the chinese would continue on a faulty project for 2 thousand years when it wasn't doing it's job very well? Or you talking about from an engineering standpoint? How nice did you expect it for being that length and taking that long to make, and going through how many dynasties and revolutions etc.. remember, they didn't have the luxury of making it slowly and it wasn't a project made by some rich fat pharoah as his resting place or place where he can stash all his bling bling, but this was a result of war, and functionality was preferred over aesthetics and mathematical beauty obviously.

    Also, saying that the great wall isn't as impressive from an engineering standpoint is pretty silly. Pyramids weren't that hard to make(imo), great wall is much harder to make and organise and bigger project in scale, and all of this during a war(and civil wars too) with ghengis khan on your doorstep.
    ______________________________
    Abstract, Negative, Concrete. Thesis, Antithesis, Synthesis. Bush, Obama, ?
    "I'd tell all my friends but they'd never believe me, They'd think that I'd finally, lost it completely. I'd show them the stars and the meaning of life.. they'd shut me away, But I'll be all right.."

    Anime/Manga List | WCR Otaku Group | The Chess Threadô | Vlog/Blog Thread | Youtube Channel

  17. #17
    700 Point Level Infernal's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2004
    Location
    Stockholm!
    Posts
    762

    Quote Originally Posted by SkyScream View Post
    We do, slaves.
    incorrect
    ______________________________
    Quote Originally Posted by ex0duz
    I know i said i wouldn't respond since i know your game of drowning in walls of text and ignoring facts, so i'll keep this short and sweet so it's obvious for everyone to see and so that there's no confusion here.
    Quote Originally Posted by Michael Myers
    After notice this terrible actor was choosen play Sabretooth choose the worst charac.

  18. #18
    500 Point Level IXioN_Hu's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2008
    Location
    -_-;;
    Posts
    570

    i like chineses more then egyptianses
    ______________________________

    click_clack_@hotmail.com<-- msn. infC.Water Looking for practice partner

  19. #19
    300 Point Level 300Spartaaa's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2007
    Location
    Maryland
    Posts
    378

    how can we vote against Necropolis on a warcraft forum. Undead REPRESENTTTTTTTTT ALIEN STYLEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE

  20. #20
    300 Point Level Ishegara's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2004
    Posts
    398

    Quote Originally Posted by ex0duz View Post
    That's the whole point. It's impressive just how much people/money they threw at it, and over how long too. Nothing else(AFAIK) can compare with such a scale of project, in the past or currently.

    But also, i'm sure the chinese could have built the pyramids, they had pretty good technology for back in the day too and came up with plenty of inventions and shit(as much or even more than the Egyptians at least, and none of this was given to them by alien civilizations ).

    And what do you mean by didn't do a very good job? They did the job, or what, did you think the chinese would continue on a faulty project for 2 thousand years when it wasn't doing it's job very well? Or you talking about from an engineering standpoint? How nice did you expect it for being that length and taking that long to make, and going through how many dynasties and revolutions etc.. remember, they didn't have the luxury of making it slowly and it wasn't a project made by some rich fat pharoah as his resting place or place where he can stash all his bling bling, but this was a result of war, and functionality was preferred over aesthetics and mathematical beauty obviously.

    Also, saying that the great wall isn't as impressive from an engineering standpoint is pretty silly. Pyramids weren't that hard to make(imo), great wall is much harder to make and organise and bigger project in scale, and all of this during a war(and civil wars too) with ghengis khan on your doorstep.
    Pyramids weren't hard to make? We can't do it today. How's that? The stones of the pyramids have incredibly close tolerances.

    The great wall is a small, simple structure repeated ad infinitum with nothing special about it and little consistency. It was really just a bunch of disconnected walls which did jack all until the Ming dynasty.

    I can draw 100 squares on 100 sheets of paper, or I can paint a landscape. 10,000 squares might take longer, but which one is more interesting and impressive?

Post New Reply

Thread Information

Users Browsing this Thread

There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)

     

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts